A man in Beijing was injured and hospitalized on his way to drink coffee and sued the cafe.

After accidentally falling on the way to the coffee shop, the parties sued the property unit, property unit and coffee shop at the destination in one breath... The reason is: they did not fulfill their safety obligations! 80% of the compensation...

(Developers, properties, coffee shops really capitalized? and n…)

Event restoration: Mr. Zhang asked a friend to go to a coffee shop to talk about something on a "dark and windy" night, so he walked according to the instructions of mobile navigation. However, there was no lighting and safety warning signs on the way to the coffee shop, and he fell down the stairs, resulting in injury and hospitalization for many days. Since the empty stairs were not marked as stairs, he did not see that the stairs were stairs. At the same time, Mr. Zhang believes that this is the developer, property and coffee shop did not fulfill the obligation to protect the safety of others in public places, this time he stepped on empty they also have responsibility, so he gave three places to sue...

Let alone property companies, developers and coffee shops are estimated to have never dreamed of such a thing…In court, developers, property companies and coffee shops said they do not agree with Mr. Zhang's petition! The developer said that the property management of the incident area had been entrusted to the property company, so Mr. Zhang had no legal basis for compensation. The coffee shop said that the incident area was a public area, not injured within the coffee shop, and they were not the managers of the incident area, so Mr. Zhang had no legal basis for asking him to assume responsibility.

The property company said that they have actually fulfilled their obligations to conduct security and fire inspection inspections in the responsible property management area. The stairs where Mr. Zhang fell belong to evacuation passages and safety exits. According to the law, the property company needs to ensure the smooth flow of the above-mentioned passages, and shall not occupy, block or close them. At the same time, he said that after the incident, monitoring was carried out to find out that the reason why Mr. Zhang stepped empty was because he bowed his head to play with his mobile phone and his attention was not concentrated. Therefore, Mr. Zhang himself also had faults this time, so he did not agree to his appeal.

Seeing this, you may think: "This is Mr. Zhang who does not look at the road!" Who is to blame..."Goose! Did he really win? After trial, the court held that the property company, as the manager of the incident area, should have the obligation to protect the safety of others. According to the on-site inspection, there are indeed potential safety hazards at the entrance of the incident area, and the property company shall take necessary safety precautions. However, the property company did not fully fulfill its security obligations, so it should bear tort liability.

But this can not completely blame the property company, Mr. Zhang bowed his head to play mobile phone is the main cause of the accident, his own fault. Therefore, the court comprehensively determined that the property unit should bear 40% of the responsibility according to the respective fault degree and causal force of both parties, and Mr. Zhang should bear 60% of the responsibility by himself.

This time, Mr. Zhang fell into hospital, hospitalization food subsidies, nursing expenses, nutrition expenses, lost time expenses, transportation expenses and medical expenses claimed for compensation totaled 186,000 yuan. Finally, the property company needs to compensate Mr. Zhang for medical expenses, hospitalization food subsidies, nutrition expenses, nursing expenses, lost time expenses and transportation expenses totaling more than 26,000 yuan... Good guy! Really good guy... Photo source: Internet

Professional coffee knowledge exchange More coffee bean information Please pay attention to coffee workshop (Weixin Official Accounts cafe_style)

More fine coffee beans, please add private WeChat Qianjie Coffee, WeChat: kaixinguoguo0925

Important Notice :

前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:

FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou

Tel:020 38364473