How to be a barista: detailed scoring criteria for COE and SCAA cup testing projects

Professional coffee knowledge exchange more coffee bean information please follow the coffee workshop (Wechat official account cafe_style)

COE, what on earth is COE?

Red wine industry has AOC level, coffee has COE level, we often hear that this is coe level, coe competition manor, the current national boutique bean competition is either CoE or SCAA mode, up to 9 major coffee producing countries have adopted Coe cup test as the national competition mode.

COE

COE is a boutique coffee competition mode, the full name is Cup Of Excellence, is a boutique coffee competition system commonly used by 10 major coffee producing countries in the world. Coffee farmers will have to take part in at least five cup tests during the three-week competition, and there will be another round of extra matches for the coffee that is in the top 10. Coffee farmers who can be selected as the winners of the COE will not only recognize the excellent quality of their coffee, but also earn a lot of money from the auction. With good auction revenue, coffee farmers have a better chance to improve their quality, and consumers have more opportunities to drink good coffee, forming a virtuous circle.

Scoring items of COE

Aroma-at this time, the cup test just began the first evaluation of the project, a total of three aroma evaluation stages, the first stage is the cup test at the beginning to smell the dry powder in the cup dry aroma, the second is the wet aroma after water injection, the third aroma is the broken residue aroma; aroma is an attractive element of coffee, coffee aroma from many sources, there are flowers, berries, caramel, nuts, chocolate, spices and so on.

The aroma of the Coe cup meter is only included in the reference, not included in the total score, but in the Flavor evaluation, the aroma is included in the score.

Cleanliness Clean cup

Cleanliness is a very important and necessary condition for fine products, which means that there are no defects and stains in the defective taste (complete freedom from taints or faults), coffee has rotten, earthy taste, medicine iodine taste, fermented acid, rubber, onions, astringency and other bad taste and touch, all indicate that it is not clean enough.

Sweetness Sweetness

Sweetness not only represents that coffee cherries are harvested in the best ripening period, not mixed with unripe beans, but also represents the excellent quality of coffee. Only by selecting freshly ripe coffee cherries to treat them into raw beans can you get better sweetness, and there are many kinds of sweetness, such as sugarcane sweetness, caramel sweetness and so on, which can be noted in the comparison. If sweetness is astringent and sweet stays in the mouth for a short time, then the sweetness score will not exceed 6 points.

Acid Acidity

Sour, good acidity is not like vinegar, even if it is bright and lively, you can detect many kinds of acidity, such as citrus, berries or sweet lemons, as well as the sweet and sour melons like cantaloupe or the crisp acidity of freshly ripe apples. The above acids are of high quality; bad acids are like unripe fruit or acetic acid, some bad acids are like overripe fruit or rotten fruit, and fermented acid or rotten acid can be detected.

Taste Mouth feel

Oral tactile evaluation is not to measure taste, it belongs to the substance and tactile sensation, grease, viscosity and quality sensation that all constitute mouth-feel;, such as milk and water. The former has much higher tactile sensation, thick soup and clear soup, the consistency and tactile sensation of the former are much higher than the latter.

Flavor Flavor

Sipping flavor, including all kinds of taste and smell, even the aroma felt in the nasal cavity and the touch of the mouth all belong to this evaluation. When testing COE cups, because 8 samples are often tested at a time, the AROMA project cannot be tested immediately, so the aroma at the beginning is only marked by pleasure and displeasure, but when it comes to sipping flavor for this evaluation, cup testers can include the aroma they feel, including various flavors measured or drunk. It can be said that sipping flavor is a very important evaluation, and it is also a basis for testing the characteristics of coffee samples.

Aftertaste Aftertaste

After sipping, the taste or aroma or touch that still stays in the mouth, and the good flavor stays for a long time, such as sweetness, remains clearly in the mouth or even scattered after sipping and spitting coffee, then the score will be high, otherwise, there will be no aftertaste, or short, the score will be low.

Equilibrium degree Balance

Refers to whether each evaluation of coffee is balanced, for example, although the acid is bright, it still turns sweet? The touch is sticky but not astringent? Are the various flavors of coffee harmonious?

Overall evaluation of Overall

Coffee is excellent on the whole and attracts you? Is it just so-so, or do you not like her at all? This evaluation is the overall assessment of the tester, and can also reflect his personal preferences.

What do you need for a cup test?

The tools needed for cup testing are simple: bean grinders, scales, thermometers, cups, spoons, and the ratio of coffee beans to water are also specified:

Water ratio: 8.25g coffee beans with 150ml water, the water temperature should be 92.2C-94.4C

Cup test cup: toughened glass or ceramic materials should be used

Cup test capacity: between 207ml and 266ml

Cup height: 3 to 3.5 inches

Mouth diameter: 76-89mm, all cups should be made of the same volume, size and material, with a lid.

Cup test spoons: to use antistatic metal material (mostly stainless steel), each spoon capacity can have 4-5ml.

The standard discrimination of COE?

The total score is 69 or less, which is a slightly worse commercial bean or industrial bean.

The total score is between 70 and 74, which belongs to general commercial beans.

The total score is between 75 and 79, and the better commercial beans are generally called high-grade commercial beans.

The total score is between 80 and 84, which belongs to fine coffee.

The total score is 85 or more, belonging to the COE competition level, is also the excellent cup of winning coffee, is currently recognized as the highest level in the international coffee industry.

In the COE score, dry incense and wet fragrance are no longer included in the total score, and the cleanliness is scored more strictly, and the flavor of aged beans caused by storage will affect the cleanliness score; sweetness will also open the difference in scores, because COE believes that high sweetness represents the altitude of coffee, and high sweetness can only be achieved when planting, harvesting and handling are excellent, and high sweetness should be rewarded. The thickness of alcohol is changed to taste, and the taste is evaluated not only on the thickness of alcohol, but also on whether it is smooth and astringent. Flavor evaluation can refer to the new version of the flavor wheel to make a more accurate evaluation.

It is a very scientific method to confirm the aroma and taste of beans, to judge the flavor and taste of coffee by cup test, and to identify the quality of a kind of coffee.

SCA

According to the SCA coffee cup test, there are ten points, of which the following two items are not available in COE:

Fragrance/Aroma aroma: the aroma consists of two parts, dry fragrance and wet fragrance. The first image of the bean grinding and the first project that needs to be scored is the dried fragrance, the aroma of coffee flowers, roasted hazelnuts and roasted almonds are all pleasant aromas. Water injection, the broken shell of the wet fragrance gives people more fantasy, honey, lemon, apricot fruit make people salivating.

Uniformity consistency: this score is relatively simple. Do 5 cups of samples have different tastes and which ones are defective?

The SCA coffee cup meter is marked from 6 points and is divided into four levels:

6 points as "good"; 7 points as "very good"; 8 points as "excellent"; 9 points as "extraordinary".

In addition, each grade is divided into four grades, and the score unit is 0.25 points, so the four levels have a total of 16 points.

How to deduct points if you find a defect?

When you find a defect, you need to determine whether it is a small defect (Taint) or a big defect (Fault).

Small defect refers to the bad smell, although obvious but not serious enough to swallow, generally refers to the defective smell of dry and wet fragrance of coffee powder that has not yet been drunk.

The big defect is that the bad smell is so serious that it hinders the mouth, generally refers to the taste and the smell behind the nose, the taste level and the defective smell of the nasal cavity after the entrance of the coffee. If there is a minor defect, 2 points per cup, and 4 points per cup if there is a big defect.

The formula is: deduction of points = number of defect cups × defect strength

The total score is then deducted from the missing points column, that is, the final score, if it is higher than 80 points, it is high-quality grade, from 80 to 100 points, divided into very good, excellent and super excellent three levels.

The process of cup testing

Take Golden Manning as an example, let's use COE's score table to do a cup test.

Preparatory work

Water; cup bowl; cup spoon; COE record sheet; coffee beans; thermometer; timer

Brew and grind all kinds of coffee beans (preferably within 24 hours)

Cup testing process

1. Grind the beans to be tested in the cup into powder (degree of grinding: BG: 3B)

two。 Smell dry aroma: control within 15 minutes

Pour water and soak in the cup according to the ratio of 8.25 grams of powder to 150 milliliters of hot water at 94 degrees Celsius. Let the coffee soak for 4 minutes until the coffee residue shell is formed.

Step 2: start timing when injecting water and smell wet incense after 2 minutes. Aroma is the intensity of the smell when brewing coffee. Some subtle and delicate differences, such as the characteristics of "floral" or "wine", come from the wet aroma of brewing coffee.

Step 3: break the dregs, stir three times on the surface of the cup with a spoon, skim off the foam and dregs, and you can start to taste the coffee with a spoon.

Step 4: taste and sip, remove the coffee scum with a cup spoon, suck the coffee entrance, feel it in the mouth and spit out the coffee liquid, record your feelings on the cup meter, score according to the requirements of the cup meter, gargle, rinse the cup and test the spoon, and then taste the next coffee.

In order to determine the baking curve suitable for [Golden Manning], we prepared three different baking degrees:

Baking curve: choose different bean temperature, 201 degrees, 202 degrees dpm 204 degrees

The ① line has aromas of milk chocolate and caramel, with aromas of berries and sweet-scented osmanthus when sipped, with a touch of dirt and rubber.

The ② line smells of spicy wood, spices and straw, with herbal and caramel flavors when sipped.

The ③ line has aromas of spices, sweet-scented osmanthus and herbs, with notes of plums, almonds, dried fruits and caramel when sipped. No matter in terms of cleanliness, acidity, sweetness and taste, these will be better than the ①② line.

Through the cup test, we can realize the flavor of the coffee itself.

Note:

For each cup of coffee sample, the cup spoon should be cleaned and rinsed with ice water to avoid affecting each other's taste.

In the same way, taste each cup of coffee sample several times until the temperature of the coffee sample drops to room temperature. Be careful to forget the previous feeling as much as possible before each coffee taste, so as to experience the next coffee sample with the purest feeling.

In the process of tasting coffee, you can spit out most of the coffee liquid. But swallow at least a small part in order to experience the feeling of the coffee sample.

Related recommendation: is hand-made coffee really good? Why does coffee smell better than it tastes?