Coffee review

What are the defective beans in coffee? Effects of primary defective beans and secondary defective beans on coffee flavor

Published: 2025-08-21 Author: World Gafei
Last Updated: 2025/08/21, Picking beans is a term that has been mentioned constantly in the boutique coffee industry in recent years. What exactly is picking beans? The coffee beans bought by ordinary consumers are roasted ripe beans, and the quality of raw beans can no longer be known. It is difficult to swallow is not terrible, terrible is the coffee beans with defective beans, after brewing may carry biotoxins, serious harm to health, so manual selection has become important and unbearable

Picking beans is a term that has been mentioned constantly in the boutique coffee industry in recent years. What exactly is picking beans?

The coffee beans bought by ordinary consumers are roasted ripe beans, and the quality of raw beans can no longer be known. It is not terrible to swallow, the terrible thing is that the coffee beans with defective beans may carry biotoxins after brewing, which is seriously harmful to health, so manual selection has become an important and not careless gatekeeper step.

Take the water washing method as an example, the color of unblemished raw coffee beans should be uniform and glossy emerald green; there are many reasons for defects, from cultivation, picking, peeling, fermentation, drying and other post-processing, and finally to the storage process is full of variables.

Of course, it is most ideal to buy raw beans with few defects from the beginning, and it is also expected as a baker, but even if the source of high-quality raw beans is advertised, the proportion of defective beans is still 30.5%, which shows that defective beans are hard to avoid.

SCAA American Fine Coffee Association (Specialty Coffee Association of America) divides defective beans into primary defects and secondary defects. Compared with secondary defective beans, primary defective beans have a more serious impact on the taste and aroma of coffee and are not allowed to appear in boutique coffee, while secondary defects are deducted according to type and quantity.

What are the first-class defective beans?

Black bean (Black Bean)

The causes of ▽ are insect pests, overripe fruits, poor drying equipment, areas with high humidity and microbial infection caused by excessive fermentation, so the bean heart, which is supposed to be turquoise, turns black.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: with rotten sour smell, musty smell, phenolic smell, etc., mixed and pungent taste, there may be biotoxins.

Fermented beans, literally translated as smelly sour beans (Sour Bean)

The cause of ▽: beans that produce contaminated fermentation are placed in fermentation buckets for too long, use contaminated water for fermentation, or dry for too long.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: similar to the sour taste of edible vinegar, the taste of bad wine fermentation, etc., spicy and unpleasant smell.

Worm-eaten bean (Insect Damaged Bean)

The cause of ▽: caused by insect pests, coffee bark beetles and other pests lay eggs on coffee trees, and the hatched larvae eat coffee fruits to form cavities; storage in harsh conditions may also occur.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: coffee produces a dull or strange smell, resulting in a reduction in wet aroma and flavor.

Moldy bean (Fungus Damaged Bean)

Showing yellow, yellowish-brown or reddish-brown spots with moldy powder.

The cause of ▽: stored in a warehouse with too high humidity, moldy beans improperly preserved, or contaminated during storage of raw beans.

✖ flavor aroma and its effects: turbid taste, reduced flavor, fermentation flavor, mildew flavor, soil flavor, phenolic flavor, etc., in which mold will produce a large number of "ochratoxin". Studies have shown that long-term low-dose intake can cause renal tubular cell necrosis, pathological changes, and even carcinogenesis.

Foreign body (Foreign Matter)

Unimaginable foreign bodies such as stones or branches must be picked out, otherwise the bean grinder may be damaged.

Don't doubt, we really picked a corn! )

The cause of ▽: it may occur in any process of raw bean treatment.

Understanding of secondary defective beans

Broken bean (Broken Bean)

The cause of ▽: beans damaged during transportation or handling.

✖ flavor, aroma and influence: affect the appearance of ripe beans, easy to cause uneven baking, may have scorched taste, too much carbonized ingredients will have adverse effects.

Shell bean (Shell Bean)

The cause of ▽: beans that become shell-shaped due to developmental problems.

✖ flavor, aroma and influence: affect the appearance of ripe beans, easy to cause uneven baking, may have scorched taste, too much carbonized ingredients will have adverse effects.

Unripe bean (Immature Bean)

(photo source: diet FoodNext)

The cause of ▽: beans harvested before the fruit is ripe may suffer from insect pests or lack of water in the process of planting.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: with a strong fishy smell, raw bitter taste.

Floating bean (Floater Bean)

The cause of ▽: it is stored in a warehouse that is too dry and too hot, or the water evaporates too much after processing.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: the fresh taste and aroma of coffee will disappear, leaving only an insipid smell.

Withered bean (Withered Bean)

The cause of ▽: when the fruit is ripe, the phenomenon of insufficient water, insufficient nutrients of coffee trees, or drastic changes in the natural environment occur.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: there is a hint of grass and soil flavor, mainly affecting the overall aroma.

Amniotic membrane bean (Parchment Bean)

Beans with incomplete shelling and residual endocarp.

The cause of ▽: the main reason is that it occurs in the process of shelling.

✖ flavor aroma and influence: residual pericarp, resulting in astringency or miscellaneous flavor.

0