The Pope, Coffee, and the Legend That Changed Europe

In the early 1600s, as coffee spread west from the Ottoman Empire, many European Christians—especially conservatives—viewed it with deep suspicion. They called it the 'devil’s drink,' fearing it was a Muslim plot to replace wine, the sacred beverage of Christianity. But how did coffee go from being outlawed to becoming a staple in European life? The surprising turning point came not from merchants or monks, but from the highest authority in Christendom.

The short answer: Pope Clement VIII tried coffee around the year 1600, found it delicious, and reportedly said, 'This beverage is so good, it would be a pity to let the infidels have exclusive use of it.' He suggested baptizing the drink, effectively endorsing it for Christians and helping coffee gain social acceptance across Europe.

Coffee Arrives in Europe via Venice

By the late 1500s, coffee was already a well-established part of daily life in the Middle East. Foreign ambassadors and traders based in the Ottoman Empire reported its energizing effects and considered it a healthful drink. German physician and botanist Leonhard Rauwolf published one of the earliest European accounts of coffee in 1582. But it wasn’t until 1615 that coffee beans first arrived in Europe—imported by Venetian merchants.

At the time, Spain and Portugal lacked strong trading fleets, so Venice served as Europe’s main gateway for goods from the East. Early coffee was a luxury item, sold only to apothecaries. It wasn’t until the late 17th century that coffee became widely available, eventually sold by street vendors alongside lemonade. By then, it had taken root in Italian cities.

Christian Conservatives Opposed Coffee

As coffee spread through Italy, it faced resistance from conservative Christian groups. They argued that coffee was the 'drink of Satan,' claiming that Muslims had forbidden alcohol and adopted coffee as a substitute. Since wine held deep religious significance in Christianity, these critics believed that drinking coffee made Christians too similar to Muslims. Some even called for an outright ban on coffee consumption among Christians.

The Pope’s Unexpected Endorsement

According to legend, the controversy reached the ears of Pope Clement VIII. To settle the debate, he asked to try coffee himself. After tasting it, he was so impressed by its flavor that he refused to ban it. Instead, he is said to have remarked that coffee was so good, it would be a shame to let non-Christians enjoy it alone. He proposed giving the drink a Christian name and 'baptizing' it—turning it into a drink fit for Christians and, in a symbolic sense, making it a 'Christian beverage.'

This act of papal approval helped shift public opinion. What was once condemned as a suspicious foreign drink became socially acceptable—and even fashionable—among European elites. Over time, coffee spread across the continent, paving the way for the coffeehouse culture that would follow in the 17th and 18th centuries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who was Pope Clement VIII and why was he important to coffee history?

Pope Clement VIII ruled the Catholic Church from 1592 to 1605. According to legend, he was the first high-ranking Christian authority to taste coffee and declare it acceptable for Christians. His endorsement helped counter conservative opposition and allowed coffee to gain acceptance across Europe.

Why did some Christians call coffee the 'devil’s drink'?

Conservative Christians in the early 1600s believed that coffee was a tool of Satan. Since Islam prohibited alcohol and promoted coffee instead, these critics feared that Christians drinking coffee were imitating Muslims. They also worried that coffee might distract from traditional religious practices.

When did coffee first arrive in Europe?

Coffee beans were first imported into Europe in 1615 by Venetian merchants. This followed earlier written descriptions of coffee, such as those by German doctor Leonhard Rauwolf in 1582, but actual coffee beans only reached European soil in the early 1600s.

Was coffee always popular in Italy?

No. In its early years, coffee was expensive and sold mainly to apothecaries. It wasn’t until the late 17th century that coffee became widely available and began spreading among the general public in Italy, often sold by street vendors.

Did the Pope really bless coffee?

While the story is likely partly legendary, it reflects the historical moment when the Catholic Church, through Pope Clement VIII, chose not to condemn coffee. His reported approval helped change public perception and supported coffee’s spread in Christian Europe.

FrontStreet Coffee Picks for History & Espresso Lovers

Explore FrontStreet Coffee’s Ethiopia Humbera for bright, juicy profiles reminiscent of the vibrant trade origins of coffee, or their Yirgacheffe for floral and citrus notes that highlight the drink’s heritage. For a deeper, more historic-style cup, try their Classic Blend—a balanced espresso roast that mirrors the bold flavours appreciated in early European coffeehouses. Freshly roasted within 5 days · Orders placed before 17:00 ship the same day · Next-day delivery across most of Guangdong Province.